Ecommerce & Retail Analysis

The real cost of selling on online marketplaces

Commission is only the start. We break down referral, fulfilment, storage, advertising, payment, returns and currency costs, with an illustrative margin example.

Key points

  • The headline commission rate is usually less than half of what a marketplace sale really costs once fulfilment, advertising, returns and payment costs are included.
  • Several platforms calculate percentage fees on the total the buyer pays, including postage and, in some cases, tax.
  • Advertising is the most variable cost and the one most likely to turn a profitable product into a loss-maker.
  • Cross-border sales add currency conversion and international fees that are easy to miss in payout reports.
  • Fee schedules change frequently. Check the official fee pages before pricing, and re-check every quarter.

Ask a marketplace seller what the platform charges and you will usually hear a single number: the commission. That figure is real, but on its own it understates what a sale actually costs, often by a wide margin. This analysis maps the full set of costs a typical seller faces, shows how they combine in an illustrative example, and sets out which ones deserve the most attention.

Why the headline rate misleads

Marketplaces publish their core fees openly, and the major platforms’ fee pages are detailed. The difficulty is not secrecy but structure. Costs are spread across several mechanisms: some are percentages, some flat amounts, some charged monthly, some only on returns or overseas orders, and some, like advertising, are set by your own bidding. They are often charged at different points and appear on different lines of the payout report. Unless you rebuild them into a per-order view, the commission line looks like the whole story.

A note on figures: marketplace fees change frequently and vary by country, category and seller type. Where we quote a number below, it was checked on the platform’s official page on 16 November 2026. Treat it as a snapshot and check the linked page before relying on it.

The cost stack, layer by layer

1. Selling plan and listing fees

Most platforms charge something just to be present. On Amazon UK, the Individual plan costs £0.75 per item sold and the Professional plan £25 a month (excluding VAT), according to Amazon’s UK pricing page. Etsy charges a flat listing fee of 0.20 USD per listing, which recurs when a listing auto-renews after a sale (Etsy Fee Basics). eBay UK gives business sellers a free listing allowance that depends on their shop subscription, with insertion fees above that.

These costs are small per order but fixed. A seller with many slow-moving listings pays them regardless of sales.

2. Referral fees, commission and final value fees

This is the headline percentage, and its structure matters as much as its level:

  • It varies by category. Amazon UK’s referral fee schedule runs from single-digit percentages in some categories to much higher rates in others, with some categories tiered by price and most carrying a per-item minimum fee.
  • It is often charged on the total, not the item price. Amazon UK calculates referral fees on the total price paid by the buyer, including delivery and gift-wrapping charges. Etsy’s 6.5% transaction fee applies to the item plus postage and gift wrap. eBay UK defines the “total amount of the sale” for its final value fee as including the item price, postage and any applicable taxes (eBay UK business seller fees). If you price “free delivery” into the item, or charge for postage, you pay commission on that money too.
  • There may be per-order add-ons. eBay UK, for example, adds a per-order fee (£0.30 for orders of £10 or less, £0.40 above) and a regulatory operating fee of 0.35% of the sale total on top of the category-based final value fee. eBay states its UK fees exclude VAT.

3. Payment processing

Some marketplaces fold payment costs into their commission. Others charge them separately. Etsy charges payment processing fees as a fixed amount plus a percentage that varies by country, calculated on the sale total including postage and any applicable sales tax. When comparing platforms, make sure you are comparing like for like: a lower commission with a separate processing fee can cost more than a higher all-in rate.

4. Fulfilment

If the marketplace stores and ships your goods, as Amazon does with its FBA programme, you pay a per-unit fulfilment fee that depends on size, weight and product type. These fees can also carry surcharges. Amazon’s UK page states that from 2 November 2026 its fuel and logistics surcharge on FBA fulfilment fees in its UK and several EU stores rose from 1.5% to 2%. If you ship orders yourself, the equivalent cost is postage, packaging and labour, which are less visible but just as real.

5. Storage

Warehouse-based programmes charge monthly storage, usually by volume. Amazon UK prices storage per cubic foot per month, with higher rates from October to December, and adds surcharges for slow-moving stock: an aged-inventory surcharge for units held more than 241 days and a storage-utilisation surcharge for sellers holding stock for long relative to their sales. Overstocking ahead of peak season can therefore become expensive quickly, especially for bulky items.

6. Advertising

On large marketplaces, organic visibility for a new or mid-ranking listing is limited, and sponsored placements sit at the top of search results. Most sellers end up paying for at least some of their traffic. Advertising is usually priced per click or as a percentage of attributed sales, and its cost depends on how many other sellers are bidding for the same searches. It is the least predictable item in the stack, and the one sellers most often leave out of their margin calculations because it is billed separately from the sale.

7. Returns

Returns cost more than the refunded price. Depending on platform and programme, a return can mean losing the outbound fulfilment fee, paying return postage, a returns-processing fee, an inspection or disposal cost, and stock that can no longer be sold as new. Commission may not be fully refunded either. Amazon UK, for example, keeps a refund administration fee of the lesser of £5 or 20% of the referral fee when you refund an order. Buyers’ statutory withdrawal rights, explained in our guide to returns, refunds and cross-border selling, mean that returns cannot simply be designed away.

8. Currency conversion and international fees

When you sell to buyers paying in another currency, someone converts the money and usually takes a margin for doing so. On eBay UK, the seller currency conversion charge for UK-registered sellers is 2.5%, rising to 2.75% from 1 December 2026, and a separate international fee applies when the buyer’s delivery address is outside the UK: 1.05% for the eurozone and Northern Europe, 1.8% for the US and Canada and 2.0% elsewhere, unless the order goes through eBay International Shipping. Conversion charges rarely appear as a separate line. They usually sit inside the exchange rate applied to your payout, so you only see them by comparing the rate you got with a reference rate.

Within the EU, the cross-border payments regulation requires payment service providers to express card currency-conversion charges as a mark-up over the European Central Bank’s reference rate, which makes comparison easier for payers. Sellers should not assume the same transparency applies to every marketplace’s own payout conversion. The mechanics are covered in our explainer on how marketplace payments work.

9. Cash-flow costs: reserves and payout timing

Not all costs are fees. Marketplaces commonly hold back part of a seller’s balance as a reserve, or release funds only after delivery is confirmed. Etsy, for instance, explains that it may place a reserve on a payment account based on risk signals such as late shipping, missing tracking or a rise in refunds, and that held funds can be released once orders are confirmed in transit (Etsy’s reserve help page). Money held for two or three weeks is money you cannot spend on stock, and for a growing seller that working-capital gap can force borrowing.

Illustrative worked example

Illustrative example only. The following uses round, hypothetical figures for a generic marketplace. It does not describe any specific platform’s fees. A UK seller sells a kitchen product for £40 with free delivery. Figures exclude VAT for simplicity.

Line Basis (illustrative) Cost per order
Sale price £40.00
Product cost (landed) £12.00
Packaging £0.60
Commission 15% of £40 £6.00
Payment processing 3% + £0.20 £1.40
Fulfilment fee Per unit £3.50
Storage Monthly cost spread per unit sold £0.40
Advertising 10% of sales £4.00
Returns allowance 8% of orders returned at about £11 each £0.90
Total costs £28.80
Contribution per order £11.20 (28%)

Three things stand out:

  1. Marketplace-related costs total £16.20, or 40.5% of the sale price, against a headline commission of 15%. The commission is less than 40% of what the platform relationship actually costs per order.
  2. Advertising is the swing factor. If advertising costs rise to 20% of sales, which can happen in competitive categories, contribution falls to £7.20 (18%). Before advertising, the product contributes £15.20. Advertising above 38% of the price means every sale loses money.
  3. Cross-border orders erode margin further. If the same item sells to a buyer in the eurozone with a 2.5% conversion charge (£1.00) and a 1% international fee (£0.40), contribution drops to £9.80 (24.5%) before any extra delivery cost.

None of these figures is unusual in structure. The point is that the line most sellers watch, commission, is not the one most likely to sink a product.

Our assessment

In our view, three features of marketplace economics deserve more attention than they get.

First, fees on the gross total quietly raise the effective rate. When commission is charged on postage and, on some platforms, on taxes, the effective rate on the seller’s net revenue is higher than the published figure. A seller who raises prices to cover free delivery also raises the commission paid.

Second, advertising has become part of the cost of access. As platforms give more search space to paid placements, organic visibility for new or mid-ranking listings has become harder to earn. That shifts cost from a predictable percentage to a variable, auction-driven one, set partly by your competitors’ budgets.

Third, fee changes arrive in small increments. A new surcharge, a rise in a conversion charge or a change to storage tiers rarely makes headlines, but each one changes unit economics. The EU’s Platform-to-Business Regulation requires online intermediation services to give business users at least 15 days’ notice of changes to their terms, which in practice is how many fee changes are communicated. Fifteen days is enough to reprice, but only if someone reads the notices. The wider regulatory picture is in our analysis of EU digital-platform rules for online sellers.

None of this makes marketplaces a bad deal. They supply demand, trust and infrastructure that would cost a great deal to replicate. But the right comparison is the full cost per order on the marketplace against the full cost of acquiring and serving the same customer elsewhere. We set out that comparison in marketplace selling vs running your own store.

How to calculate your own true cost

  1. Download a month of settlement or payout reports from each marketplace, not just the sales summary.
  2. Map every fee line to an order, including advertising, storage and returns, which are often billed separately.
  3. Calculate contribution per order by product, not just in aggregate. Averages hide loss-making lines.
  4. Separate domestic and cross-border orders to see the effect of conversion and international fees.
  5. Model your sensitivity to advertising cost and return rate, the two most volatile inputs.
  6. Set a floor price for each product below which it should not be sold or advertised.
  7. Re-check fee pages quarterly and whenever a platform sends notice of changed terms.

Bottom line

The real cost of selling on a marketplace is the sum of nine or more charges, not one. In our illustrative example the platform-related costs came to about 2.7 times the headline commission. Sellers who model the full stack can price confidently and decide which products deserve advertising. Those who track only commission tend to find out about the rest when the payouts arrive.

Sources and further reading

  1. Amazon UK selling fees and pricing — Amazon
  2. Fees for business sellers — eBay UK Help
  3. Etsy Fee Basics — Etsy Help Centre
  4. What is a Payment Account Reserve? — Etsy Help Centre
  5. Regulation (EU) 2019/1150 on promoting fairness and transparency for business users of online intermediation services — EUR-Lex
  6. Regulation (EU) 2021/1230 on cross-border payments in the Union — EUR-Lex