Marketplace selling vs running your own online store: how to choose

A practical framework for choosing between marketplaces such as Amazon, eBay or Etsy and your own store, covering costs, control, customer data and risk.

Key points

  • Marketplaces trade margin and control for access to buyers who are already searching; your own store trades the reverse.
  • Compare channels on contribution margin per order after every fee, advertising and return, not on headline commission rates.
  • On a marketplace the customer relationship, the rules and your payouts all sit with the platform. Plan for suspension, delisting and fee changes.
  • EU and UK rules give marketplace sellers some protection, such as notice periods and reasons for restrictions, but do not remove platform dependence.
  • For most small sellers the realistic answer is sequenced: use a marketplace to validate demand, then build a direct channel that you control.

Every small online business eventually faces the same fork: sell through a marketplace where the buyers already are, or build a store of your own where the rules, the data and the margin are yours. The question is usually framed as either/or, but it is really about sequencing and dependence: which channel you lead with, how much of your revenue you let one platform control, and what you need to have in place before you shift the balance.

What you are actually choosing between

A marketplace such as Amazon, eBay or Etsy is an intermediary. It owns the storefront, the search engine that decides which listings buyers see, the checkout, and usually the payment flow. You supply products, listings and fulfilment (or pay the marketplace to fulfil for you), and the platform takes a share of each sale plus whatever else you opt into.

An independent store, whether built on a hosted platform like Shopify, an open-source system like WooCommerce or something bespoke, is a shop you operate. You choose the design, set the policies within the law, pick a payment provider and own the customer list. You also own the hardest problem in ecommerce: getting people to visit in the first place.

Most of the trade-offs follow from that difference. A marketplace sells you access to demand. An independent store sells you control, and leaves demand to you.

The case for marketplaces

Demand already exists

The main reason to start on a marketplace is that buyers arrive with intent. Someone searching Etsy for “hand-thrown stoneware mug” is a few clicks from buying. A new independent store has no such traffic. It has to earn it through search optimisation, social media, paid advertising or partnerships, all of which take time or money.

Trust is borrowed

First-time buyers hesitate to give card details to an unknown shop. On a marketplace the platform’s own buyer protection, review system and checkout carry much of that trust for you. For a newcomer this matters more than any feature list. It is also something an independent store has to build deliberately, a topic we cover in how small online retailers build customer trust.

Operations come bundled

Marketplaces handle payment processing, fraud screening, and in some programmes warehousing and delivery. Amazon’s Fulfilment by Amazon, for example, stores, picks, packs and ships your stock for a per-unit fulfilment fee plus monthly storage charges, according to Amazon’s UK pricing page. For a one-person business, outsourcing that complexity can be worth a lot.

Some compliance work is shared

Platforms also carry obligations that touch your business. Under the Digital Services Act, online marketplaces serving EU consumers must collect and make reasonable efforts to verify trader information before letting traders sell, and must design their interfaces so that traders can display required product-safety and pre-contract information. That does not take the legal responsibility off you. You are still the trader, and under the General Product Safety Regulation your listings must carry the required product and manufacturer details. But the platform’s structured listing fields at least prompt you to provide them.

The case for your own store

Margin

Marketplace fees stack. Etsy charges a listing fee and a transaction fee on the order total (including postage), plus payment processing fees that vary by country, according to its fee basics page. Amazon charges a selling-plan fee and a category-based referral fee with a per-item minimum, before fulfilment, storage and advertising. On your own store you still pay for payment processing, the platform subscription, apps, hosting and marketing, but you are not paying a commission on every order. Whether that leaves you better off depends on what you spend to bring customers in. We break the full stack down in the real cost of selling on online marketplaces.

The customer relationship

On most marketplaces the platform owns the relationship. Buyers’ contact details may be restricted or masked, and messaging tools are usually limited to order-related communication. You cannot freely email a past buyer about a new collection. On your own store, a buyer who opts in to marketing becomes a customer you can reach again at little cost, subject to data-protection and electronic-marketing law. Repeat purchases from people you can contact are among the cheapest sales a small retailer can make.

Brand and presentation

Marketplace listings are standardised: the same templates, the same “buy box” or listing layout, often a competitor’s product a scroll away. Your own store lets you tell the story behind the product, bundle items, set your own returns policy above the legal minimum and design a checkout that suits your customers.

Control over the rules

This is the factor sellers tend to underweight until it bites. On a marketplace, the platform sets and changes the fees, the ranking logic, the category rules, the payout schedule and the account-health thresholds. It can restrict listings or suspend accounts. On your own store, you answer to the law, your payment provider and your hosting platform’s terms, but nobody else decides whether your product appears.

Dependence and platform risk

A business that makes 90% of its revenue on one marketplace has, in effect, one customer: the platform. Everything that platform decides flows straight to your profit and loss account.

The EU’s Platform-to-Business Regulation (P2B) puts some guardrails around that relationship. Among other things, online intermediation services must give business users at least 15 days’ notice of changes to their terms, must give a statement of reasons when they restrict or suspend a seller, and generally must give 30 days’ notice before terminating a seller altogether. They must also describe the main parameters that determine ranking and run an internal complaint-handling system. The UK kept its own version of these rules after Brexit. These are real protections. A sudden fee rise or a suspension without explanation is not simply something you have to accept. But they regulate how decisions are made and communicated, not what the platform decides. A fee increase announced with proper notice is still a fee increase.

In our view, the practical risk for most small sellers is not a dramatic ban. It is the gradual squeeze: a few tenths of a percentage point added to fees, advertising costs rising as more sellers bid on the same searches, or an algorithm change that moves your listings from page one to page three. You cannot negotiate with any of these. You can only reduce your exposure. For a fuller look at how EU platform rules apply to sellers, see our analysis of EU digital-platform rules for online sellers.

Tax reporting: the same either way

One persistent myth is that selling on a marketplace is somehow less visible to the tax authorities. The opposite is now true. Under the EU’s DAC7 directive, platform operators must collect information on sellers and report their income to tax authorities. The UK has equivalent reporting rules for digital platforms, and HMRC’s guidance explains that the main exclusion for small sellers of goods covers those with fewer than 30 sales and €2,000 (about £1,700) or less in a year. If you sell more than that, assume your platform income is reported. That has no bearing on which channel you choose, but it removes one bad reason for preferring marketplaces.

A framework for deciding

Rather than asking which channel is better, work through five questions about your own business.

  1. Is there existing search demand for what you sell? If buyers already search marketplaces for your product category, a marketplace gets you in front of them straight away. If your product is new, niche or needs explaining, marketplace search may not help much, and your own content and community will do more of the work.
  2. What is your contribution margin per order on each channel? Take the sale price and subtract product cost, packaging, delivery, every platform or payment fee, advertising per order and an allowance for returns. Do this for a marketplace and for your own store, using realistic advertising costs for the store. A product with thin margins may not survive marketplace fees. A product with healthy margins may not survive the cost of acquiring customers directly.
  3. How often do customers buy again? Consumables, refills and collectables reward owning the customer relationship. A one-off purchase, such as a sofa or a wedding gift, reduces that advantage.
  4. What can you operate? An independent store needs someone to handle site maintenance, payment disputes, customer service and, crucially, marketing. If nobody on the team can drive traffic, a beautifully built store will sit empty.
  5. How much platform risk can you absorb? If losing a marketplace account for a month would end the business, that is a signal to diversify, whatever the current numbers say.

How the answers usually play out

Situation Typical starting point Why
New seller, commodity-like products, existing search demand Marketplace first Demand and trust are borrowed; testing is cheap
Distinctive brand, story-led products, strong social following Own store first, marketplace optional Audience exists; margin and data matter more
High repeat-purchase products (consumables, refills) Both, with own store as the destination Use marketplace for discovery, own store for retention
Low-margin, bulky or fragile goods Own store or carefully selected marketplace Fulfilment and commission can erase margin
Handmade or vintage goods Specialist marketplace plus own store Niche marketplaces bring targeted buyers

Illustrative scenarios

These are hypothetical businesses, used to show how the framework works.

A ceramics maker in Bristol sells mugs and bowls at £25–£45. There is clear search demand on Etsy for handmade ceramics, and the maker has no marketing budget. Etsy is a sensible first channel. As repeat buyers appear, a simple independent store with a mailing list lets the maker sell directly to people who already know the work, with Etsy left in place for discovery.

A German fashion label with a growing Instagram following and an average order of €90 has its own audience already. Starting on its own store protects margin and lets it collect first-party data for retargeting and email. A large fashion marketplace might later be added to reach shoppers in France or Italy without building local demand from scratch, accepting lower margin on those sales.

A UK supplements brand sells a product people reorder monthly. Marketplace search brings new customers efficiently, but every reorder placed there pays commission again. The logical structure is to use the marketplace to acquire customers and give them good reasons, such as subscriptions and loyalty pricing, to reorder on the brand’s own store, while respecting each marketplace’s rules on contacting buyers.

What a multichannel setup requires

Most growing sellers end up on more than one channel. That works only if the operational basics are in place:

  • Single inventory record. Stock must sync across channels, or you will oversell and pay for it in cancellations and account-health penalties.
  • Channel-level profitability. Track margin per channel, not just revenue. A channel can grow while losing money. Our guide to using analytics to improve conversion covers how to set up meaningful measurement.
  • Consistent policies. Returns, delivery times and product information should not contradict each other between your store and your marketplace listings.
  • Pricing discipline. Some marketplaces monitor prices elsewhere and may reduce your visibility if your item is cheaper on another site. Read each platform’s pricing policies before setting a lower price on your own store.

Bottom line

Marketplaces are a fast, relatively low-risk way to find out whether people will buy what you make, and for some products they remain the best channel indefinitely. But revenue on a marketplace is rented, not owned. In our assessment, the sustainable position for most small sellers is a deliberate mix: marketplaces for discovery and volume, an independent store for margin, loyalty and resilience, and a clear view of what each channel really earns.

What to do next

  • Calculate contribution margin per order for your top five products on each channel you use or are considering.
  • Write down what would happen to the business if your main marketplace account were suspended for 30 days.
  • If you rely heavily on one platform, set a target share of revenue from channels you control, and a date by which to reach it.
  • For tactics on standing out against much larger competitors, read how small retailers can compete with larger platforms.

Sources and further reading

  1. Regulation (EU) 2019/1150 on promoting fairness and transparency for business users of online intermediation services — EUR-Lex
  2. Regulation (EU) 2022/2065 (Digital Services Act) — EUR-Lex
  3. Council Directive (EU) 2021/514 (DAC7) on administrative cooperation in the field of taxation — EUR-Lex
  4. Check if you need to register as a digital platform operator — HM Revenue & Customs (GOV.UK)
  5. Amazon UK selling fees and pricing — Amazon
  6. Etsy Fee Basics — Etsy Help Centre
  7. Regulation (EU) 2023/988 on general product safety — EUR-Lex