Returns, refunds and cross-border selling: EU and UK rules for online shops
The 14-day withdrawal right, refund deadlines, return costs, the EU online withdrawal function, legal guarantees and cross-border rules for online sellers.
An analysis of how the DSA, DMA, P2B Regulation, GPSR and Omnibus Directive shape what marketplace sellers must provide, display and expect from platforms.
Most EU platform legislation is addressed to the platforms themselves, but a seller listing products on a marketplace feels its effects every day: in the identity checks at onboarding, the mandatory fields on a product page, the rules on discounts and reviews, and the reasons a listing disappears. This analysis sets out what five instruments mean for sellers in practice, where enforcement stands in November 2026, and what we expect to change.
The Digital Services Act has applied to all intermediary services since 17 February 2024. Its marketplace provisions, in Section 4 of Chapter III, apply to online platforms that allow consumers to conclude distance contracts with traders. Micro and small platforms are exempt unless designated as very large.
Before a trader can offer products to EU consumers, the marketplace must obtain its name, address, telephone number and email address; an identification document or electronic identification; payment account details; registration in a trade or similar register where applicable; and a self-certification that the trader will offer only products that comply with EU law. The platform must make best efforts to assess whether that information is reliable, using freely available official databases or by asking for supporting documents. If the information proves inaccurate or incomplete and is not corrected, the platform must suspend the trader.
Part of this information, including the trader’s name, address, contact details and trade register number, must be shown to consumers on the platform. For a sole trader working from home, that means the business address becomes visible to buyers; some use a separate business address for this reason. Our guide to marketplace seller onboarding and verification covers the documents platforms typically request.
Article 31 obliges marketplaces to design their interfaces so that traders can provide the pre-contractual, compliance and product safety information required by EU law, including product identification, trader identification and any required labelling. In practice this is why marketplace listing forms have acquired fields for manufacturer details, responsible persons and safety warnings. The platform must make reasonable efforts to check that traders have completed them before the offer goes live, and to make random checks against official databases for illegal products.
Article 32 requires a platform that becomes aware an illegal product has been sold through it to inform the buyers, where it has their contact details, including the trader’s identity and any means of redress.
The Commission enforces the DSA directly against very large online platforms. In 2026 it adopted two marketplace decisions. On 28 May it fined Temu €200 million, finding that its risk assessment failed to identify and assess properly the risk of illegal products reaching EU consumers. On 20 July it fined AliExpress €550 million for failures to assess and mitigate the risk of illegal, unsafe and counterfeit goods. Both companies have publicly disputed the decisions and can challenge them in court.
Our assessment: these decisions concern systemic risk duties that apply only to the largest platforms, not to sellers. But the remedy for a platform that has been fined for letting illegal products through is more vetting, more automated listing checks and faster delisting. Sellers on every large marketplace should expect stricter documentation requests and less tolerance for incomplete product data.
The Digital Markets Act imposes obligations on designated gatekeepers rather than sellers. Several matter to businesses that sell through or advertise on gatekeeper services. Gatekeepers may not prevent business users from offering different prices or conditions through other channels, including their own websites (Article 5(3)). They may not rank their own products more favourably than comparable third-party products (Article 6(5)). Business users are entitled to access, free of charge, data generated by their use of the platform (Article 6(10)).
Amazon’s marketplace is among the designated core platform services. Facebook Marketplace’s designation was revoked by the Commission in April 2025 and, separately, annulled by the General Court in June 2026. The first DMA non-compliance fines, against Apple and Meta in April 2025, concerned app-store steering and Meta’s advertising model rather than marketplaces. For sellers, the most practical DMA right is the data-access obligation: if you sell on a gatekeeper marketplace, it is worth asking what data the platform makes available to you and in what format.
The Platform-to-Business Regulation, applicable since 12 July 2020, is the one instrument written to protect sellers. It requires platforms to:
The Commission’s Digital Omnibus package of November 2025 proposes repealing the P2B Regulation on the ground that the DSA and DMA now cover much of the same ground. Several member states have objected, notably to losing the internal complaint-handling right. As of November 2026 the proposal is under negotiation and the regulation remains in force. In our view, sellers should keep using its rights: a written statement of reasons is often the fastest route to reinstating a wrongly suspended listing.
The General Product Safety Regulation has applied since 13 December 2024 to consumer products not covered by more specific EU safety law, and fills gaps where sector rules (such as those for toys or electrical equipment) are silent.
For anyone selling at a distance, Article 19 is the key provision. Every online offer must clearly display the manufacturer’s name, postal and electronic address; where the manufacturer is outside the EU, the name and contact details of the responsible economic operator in the EU; information identifying the product, including a picture and type; and any warning or safety information in a language easily understood by consumers in the member state concerned. A product from a non-EU manufacturer cannot be placed on the EU market without an economic operator established in the EU responsible for it (Article 16 of the GPSR, read with Article 4 of Regulation (EU) 2019/1020).
Marketplaces have their own duties under Article 22: registering a single point of contact on the Safety Gate portal, acting on orders from authorities to remove dangerous products, and designing interfaces that let traders display the Article 19 information. Manufacturers must report accidents caused by their products through the Safety Business Gateway, and in a recall must offer consumers an effective remedy (repair, replacement or refund, under Article 37).
Illustrative example: a German retailer imports children’s lamps from a supplier in Asia and sells them on two marketplaces. Unless the supplier has an EU-based responsible person, the retailer is likely to become the importer, with the documentation, labelling and traceability duties that entails. Missing manufacturer details are one of the most common reasons marketplaces now block listings.
The Omnibus Directive, applicable since 28 May 2022, amended four consumer-law directives. Three changes bear directly on sellers’ own conduct.
Fake reviews. Under the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive as amended, traders that give access to consumer reviews must say whether and how they ensure reviews come from people who actually used or bought the product. It is blacklisted, meaning always unfair, to claim reviews are genuine without taking reasonable and proportionate steps to check, and to submit, commission or misrepresent fake reviews or endorsements, including selectively publishing only positive ones. Paying for reviews through a third-party service falls squarely within the ban.
Price reductions. The amended Price Indication Directive requires any announced price reduction to show the prior price, being the lowest price applied in the preceding 30 days. In Aldi Süd (C-330/23), decided on 26 September 2024, the Court of Justice held that the advertised reduction itself, whether a percentage or a “price highlight”, must be calculated from that 30-day lowest price. Raising a price shortly before a sale to inflate the discount does not work.
Ranking transparency. When consumers can search across products from different traders, the platform must disclose the main ranking parameters and their relative importance, and paid placement must be clearly disclosed. Marketplaces must also tell consumers whether the seller is a trader or a private individual, which affects whether consumer-law protections apply.
Penalties for widespread infringements were raised to at least 4% of annual turnover in the member states concerned, or €2 million where turnover data is unavailable.
On 11 November 2026 the Commission adopted its proposal for a Digital Fairness Act, together with a companion simplification directive. According to law-firm summaries of the text, it would take the form of a regulation repealing and replacing the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive, with new rules on dark patterns, influencer marketing, subscriptions and personalised pricing, and would give the Commission direct enforcement powers in some cross-border cases. It is at the start of the legislative process and would apply 12 months after entry into force, so it changes nothing yet. Its interaction with the platform rules above will become clearer during negotiations.
Taken together, these instruments shift compliance work upstream onto sellers while making platforms the enforcers. The DSA and GPSR oblige marketplaces to check what sellers provide; the 2026 fines give them strong reasons to check strictly. For sellers, this has two consequences. Product and identity data has become a precondition of selling rather than an administrative afterthought, and the cost of keeping it current belongs in any calculation of the true cost of selling on marketplaces. And sellers have a stake in which marketplaces do this well: platforms that verify traders and remove unsafe goods consistently are, in our view, the ones that build durable consumer trust.
This article is general information, not legal advice; for decisions about your business, consult a qualified adviser.
The 14-day withdrawal right, refund deadlines, return costs, the EU online withdrawal function, legal guarantees and cross-border rules for online sellers.
The EU's Omnibus Directive entered into force on 7 January 2020; a day later the UK CMA won fake-review pledges from Facebook and eBay. What changed, and what followed.
Identity checks, honest reviews, protected payments, fair disputes and open rules on ranking and fees: how to judge whether a marketplace deserves your trust.