Marketplace selling vs running your own online store: how to choose
A practical framework for choosing between marketplaces such as Amazon, eBay or Etsy and your own store, covering costs, control, customer data and risk.
From card authorisation to payout: acquirers, PSPs, split payments, SCA, chargebacks, payout holds, reserves and currency conversion, explained for sellers.
When a buyer taps “pay” on a marketplace, the money does not travel straight to the seller. It passes through banks, networks and payment providers, sits with the marketplace or its payment partner, and arrives days or weeks later, net of fees, possibly converted, and still reversible. This explainer follows that journey and sets out what sellers need to understand at each stage.
Card payments remain the backbone of most marketplace checkouts. Wallets such as Apple Pay and Google Pay usually run on card rails underneath.
| Party | Role |
|---|---|
| Cardholder | The buyer, paying with a debit or credit card |
| Issuer | The buyer’s bank, which issued the card and approves or declines the payment |
| Card scheme | The network (Visa, Mastercard, American Express and others) that sets the rules and routes messages between issuer and acquirer |
| Acquirer | The bank or licensed institution that contracts with the merchant to accept card payments and receives the funds from the scheme |
| Payment service provider (PSP) | The company that provides the checkout technology and often the acquiring relationship, such as Stripe, Adyen or PayPal |
| Merchant | The business in whose name the payment is accepted. On a marketplace this may be the platform, the seller, or the platform acting on the seller’s behalf |
A payment moves in three stages. At authorisation, the issuer checks that the card is valid, the funds or credit are available and the transaction does not look fraudulent, then approves or declines in seconds. At clearing, the transaction details are exchanged between acquirer and issuer through the scheme. At settlement, money moves from the issuer to the acquirer, and from the acquirer to the merchant or PSP, usually within a few business days.
Each stage carries costs. The issuer receives an interchange fee, which in the EEA is capped for most consumer cards at 0.2% of the transaction value for debit cards and 0.3% for credit cards under the Interchange Fee Regulation. The scheme charges scheme fees, and the acquirer or PSP adds its own margin. On a marketplace these costs are usually bundled into a payment processing fee or into the commission itself, which is why sellers rarely see them separately.
A marketplace collects money from a buyer for goods sold by someone else. That simple fact has significant regulatory consequences.
Holding and passing on money that belongs to third parties is a regulated payment service in the EU under the second Payment Services Directive (PSD2) and in the UK under the Payment Services Regulations 2017. PSD2 contains an exclusion for commercial agents, but it applies only where the agent is authorised to negotiate or conclude sales on behalf of only the payer or only the payee. The directive’s recitals add that where an agent acts for both sides, as many ecommerce platforms do, it can rely on the exclusion only if it never takes possession or control of client funds. A marketplace that collects the buyer’s money and later pays the seller does exactly that. In practice, most marketplaces either:
The second model is common for small and mid-sized marketplaces. In card-scheme terms it often resembles a payment facilitator arrangement: a provider, sponsored by an acquirer, onboards many smaller “sub-merchants” under its own acquiring relationship rather than each seller contracting with an acquirer directly.
Because the regulated entity is responsible for the funds, it must know who it is paying. Hence identity, business-registration, beneficial-ownership and bank-account checks at onboarding, and paused payouts when documents expire or details change. We cover this process in marketplace seller onboarding and verification.
The defining feature of marketplace payments is the split: one buyer payment, divided between one or more sellers, the marketplace’s commission and the payment provider’s fees. Payment providers implement this in different ways, and the choice determines who appears on the buyer’s statement and who absorbs refunds and disputes.
Stripe’s documentation for its Connect product offers a clear illustration of the main models:
Other providers use different terms, but the questions are the same: who is the merchant of record, and who bears refunds and chargebacks? Even where the platform is the merchant of record, marketplace terms almost always allow it to recover refunds, chargebacks and associated fees from the seller’s balance or future payouts.
Funds are released on a schedule that depends on the platform, the seller’s history and, increasingly, delivery: a fixed cycle, a set number of days after confirmed delivery, or longer delays for new sellers. Payouts are net of commission, payment fees, advertising and any refunds or chargebacks, so they rarely match gross sales.
A reserve is part of a seller’s balance that the marketplace or its payment partner holds back to cover expected refunds and chargebacks. Reserves may be:
Etsy, for example, says it may place a reserve on a seller’s payment account based on signals such as late shipping, orders without tracking or a recent increase in refunds, and that held funds can be released once orders are confirmed in transit (Etsy Help Centre). Other marketplaces use comparable mechanisms under different names.
Reserves are rarely negotiable, but they respond to behaviour: shipping on time with tracking and keeping refund and dispute rates low reduce the chance of a hold. We include the cash-flow effect in our breakdown of the real cost of selling on online marketplaces.
PSD2 requires strong customer authentication (SCA) when a payer initiates an electronic payment, subject to exemptions. SCA means verifying the payer using at least two independent elements from different categories: something they know (a password or PIN), something they have (a phone or card) and something they are (a fingerprint or face). For online card payments it is usually delivered through 3-D Secure, the familiar banking-app or one-time-code step.
The detailed rules sit in the regulatory technical standards on SCA, which also set the exemptions a payment provider can request, including:
Payments initiated by the merchant under a previously authenticated agreement, such as an instalment or a later charge for a split shipment, are generally treated as outside SCA’s scope. The UK applies its own version of these rules through the Payment Services Regulations and FCA technical standards.
For sellers, SCA matters for two reasons. The issuer has the final say and can insist on authentication, adding checkout friction. And a payment authenticated through 3-D Secure normally shifts liability for most fraud-related chargebacks from the merchant to the issuer.
At the time of writing, PSD2 remains the operative law. The EU has agreed a replacement package: a third Payment Services Directive (PSD3) and a directly applicable Payment Services Regulation (PSR). The European Commission records a political agreement between Parliament and Council on 27 November 2025. As of mid-November 2026, however, the texts had not been published in the Official Journal, and the new rules are expected to apply only after a transition period. Sellers do not need to act yet; marketplaces and their payment partners will adjust checkout and onboarding flows as the rules take effect.
A chargeback occurs when a cardholder disputes a payment with their issuer and the issuer reverses it through the card scheme. Common reasons are suspected fraud, goods not received, goods not as described, and duplicate or incorrect charges.
The timeline is longer than many sellers expect. According to Stripe’s dispute documentation, card networks typically allow cardholders to dispute within 120 days of the payment, and sometimes longer. Once a dispute is opened, the merchant usually has 7–21 days to respond, the issuer then has around 60–75 days to decide, and the full process can take two to three months. The disputed amount is taken from the merchant’s balance when the dispute opens, usually with a dispute fee, and is returned only if the merchant wins.
Two details catch sellers out. If the sale involved currency conversion, the amount debited can differ from the original sale because exchange rates have moved. And on many marketplaces the platform settles the buyer’s claim through its own protection scheme before any chargeback, then deducts the cost from the seller under its terms.
In the UK, buyers who pay by credit card for items priced between £100 and £30,000 also have rights under section 75 of the Consumer Credit Act, which can make the card issuer jointly liable for breach of contract or misrepresentation. That is another route by which a disputed sale can be reversed. For practical prevention measures, see our guide to payment fraud prevention for smaller businesses.
Cross-border marketplace sales can involve currency conversion at several points:
Each conversion can carry a margin over the wholesale exchange rate. Within the EU, the cross-border payments regulation requires card currency-conversion charges to be expressed as a mark-up over the European Central Bank’s reference rates, making them easier to compare. Marketplaces’ own seller conversion charges are set in their terms and can change. eBay UK, for instance, has announced that its seller currency conversion charge for UK-registered sellers will rise from 2.5% to 2.75% on 1 December 2026. Where a marketplace allows it, receiving payouts in the sale currency can reduce conversion costs, provided you have costs in that currency or can convert more cheaply elsewhere.
| Question | Where to find the answer |
|---|---|
| Who is the merchant of record, and whose name appears on the buyer’s statement? | Marketplace seller terms and payment terms |
| Which regulated entity holds my funds? | Payment terms, payments provider’s terms |
| When are funds released, and what triggers a reserve? | Payout and reserve help pages |
| How are refunds and chargebacks recovered from me? | Seller terms, dispute policy |
| What conversion margin applies to cross-border sales and payouts? | Fee schedule, currency conversion terms |
| Can I respond to disputes myself, or does the platform decide? | Buyer-protection and dispute policies |
For a marketplace seller, payment is a process, not an event: authorisation, settlement, holding, payout and, sometimes, reversal months later. Payout timing, reserves, chargeback exposure and conversion margins shape cash flow as much as fees do. Sellers who understand how the money moves can read payout reports accurately and plan working capital. For a wider comparison of channels, see marketplace selling vs running your own store, and for buyers’ rights when orders go wrong across borders, our guide to returns, refunds and cross-border selling.
This article is general information, not legal or financial advice.
A practical framework for choosing between marketplaces such as Amazon, eBay or Etsy and your own store, covering costs, control, customer data and risk.
Commission is only the start. We break down referral, fulfilment, storage, advertising, payment, returns and currency costs, with an illustrative margin example.
Card-not-present fraud, chargebacks, SCA and 3-D Secure, fraud screening and PCI DSS v4.0.1 scope explained for small online merchants, with a checklist.