Marketplace selling vs running your own online store: how to choose
A practical framework for choosing between marketplaces such as Amazon, eBay or Etsy and your own store, covering costs, control, customer data and risk.
A look back at the 2019 European Ecommerce Report forecast, how later editions revised it, and how sellers should read market-size figures today.
In June 2019 two Brussels trade bodies published a headline that travelled widely: European online retail would be worth about €621 billion that year. Seven years on, the number is worth revisiting less for what it said about 2019 than for what happened to it afterwards, and for what that teaches anyone who uses market-size statistics to plan a business.
On 11 June 2019 Ecommerce Europe and EuroCommerce jointly launched the European Ecommerce Report 2019. Their press release said European business-to-consumer (B2C) ecommerce turnover had risen by 11.87% to €547 billion in 2018 and was forecast to grow by “close to 14%” to €621 billion in 2019. The report itself, in Ecommerce Europe’s foreword, described the expected growth as around 13%; the arithmetic from €547 billion to €621 billion is roughly 13.5%, so the difference is rounding rather than substance.
Two points about provenance matter. First, the €621 billion was a forecast, published halfway through the year it described. Second, the research was not carried out by either association. The report credits Ecommerce Foundation’s research team (through its Ecommerce Operations organisation) with preparing it, drawing on data supplied by national ecommerce associations alongside national statistics offices, Eurostat and commercial data providers. Later editions were prepared by different research partners, which becomes important below.
The 2019 report used a broad, geographic definition of Europe, not the European Union. Its five regions included non-EU markets such as the UK, Switzerland, Norway and Iceland, as well as Russia, Ukraine, Serbia, North Macedonia and Turkey. Anyone comparing the €621 billion with an EU-only figure was comparing different things.
The report’s regional split showed how concentrated the market was. Western Europe (the Netherlands, Belgium, the UK, Ireland, France, Luxembourg and Germany) accounted for about 66% of turnover, or €363 billion. Southern Europe followed with 14% (€78 billion) and Northern Europe with 9% (€49 billion). Northern Europeans, however, spent the most per online shopper, at a little over €2,000 a year.
Adoption varied just as sharply. The report put online shopping rates for 2018 at 88% in Switzerland, 87% in the UK and 86% in Denmark, against 31% in Bulgaria, 26% in Romania and 22% in Ukraine. It also highlighted cross-border buying in small markets: 89% of Maltese online shoppers had bought from a seller in another EU country. Among the reasons people gave for not shopping online were delivery times, worries about receiving and returning goods, complaints and redress, and payment security.
The most instructive part of this story is what later editions said about the same year.
| Edition | Published | 2019 turnover stated | Prepared by |
|---|---|---|---|
| European Ecommerce Report 2019 | June 2019 | €621bn (forecast) | Ecommerce Foundation |
| European Ecommerce Regional Report 2020 | July 2020 | €636bn | RetailX |
| European E-commerce Report 2021 | September 2021 | €690bn | Centre for Market Insights, Amsterdam University of Applied Sciences |
In July 2020 EuroCommerce reported that 2019 had come in at €636 billion, up 14.2%, and forecast about €717 billion for 2020. It cautioned that the full effect of the pandemic would only show the following year.
The September 2021 edition, the first prepared by the Centre for Market Insights at the Amsterdam University of Applied Sciences, restated 2019 as €690 billion and put 2020 at €757 billion. By then the 2019 figure was about 11% higher than the original forecast. In our assessment, most of that gap reflects a rebuilt series, with a new research partner and new data sources, rather than anything that happened in 2019 itself.
The popular memory of 2020 is an ecommerce boom, and for physical goods it was. Yet the 2021 report put total European growth in 2020 at 10%, down from 14% in 2019. Its explanation was that a sharp fall in online sales of travel, events and tickets held back the overall figure. Because the headline total included services, a surge in online grocery and home goods sat alongside a collapse in online bookings.
Revisions have not stopped. In September 2025 the associations first reported 2024 turnover of €819 billion, then issued a corrigendum on 10 October 2025 that put it at €842 billion.
The latest edition, the European E-commerce Report 2026, was presented on 22 September 2026 and again prepared by the Centre for Market Insights. According to the press release and executive summary, it covers 38 European countries and found:
Even this edition illustrates the revision problem. The press release gives the 2024 baseline as €842 billion, while the executive summary gives €852 billion; both describe 2025 growth as 7%. More usefully, the executive summary states plainly that each country applies its own methodology and that the extent to which services are included in turnover figures varies widely, so direct comparisons between countries should be made with caution.
Set against the 2019 report, the regional picture has shifted. Western Europe’s share has fallen from about two-thirds to 57%, while the fastest growth has moved south and east. (Country coverage and methods have changed between editions, so the comparison is indicative rather than exact.)
Industry reports estimate market value. Eurostat, the EU’s statistical office, measures something different and does so with a stable, harmonised survey method.
Its statistics on individuals come from an annual household survey. The latest article, with data extracted in February 2026, reports that 78% of EU internet users aged 16–74 bought or ordered goods or services online in the 12 months before the 2025 survey. Its enterprise statistics cover firms with ten or more employees: in 2024, 23.59% of EU enterprises made e-sales, e-sales made up 19.49% of total turnover, and web sales to consumers accounted for 4.04% of turnover.
Neither indicator gives a euro value for the B2C market, and the enterprise survey excludes the smallest businesses, which many independent sellers are. But both are comparable across member states and over time in a way that a stitched-together market estimate is not.
In our view, the 2019 episode suggests a short checklist for anyone using a headline figure to size an opportunity or justify an investment.
Illustrative example: a seller planning to enter Poland might see strong regional growth in the industry report, then check Eurostat’s share of Polish internet users who buy online and the share of firms selling through marketplaces, before testing demand on a marketplace rather than committing to a local store. Our guides to marketplace selling versus running your own store and the real cost of selling on marketplaces cover that decision, and our analysis of EU digital-platform rules for online sellers covers the regulatory side of selling across borders.
The €621 billion forecast was a reasonable snapshot from the data available in mid-2019, and the direction it pointed in, steady double-digit growth concentrated in Western Europe, was broadly right at the time. Its exact level did not survive later revisions. For sellers, the practical lesson is to treat any single market-size figure as an estimate with a definition attached, and to read the definition before the number.
A practical framework for choosing between marketplaces such as Amazon, eBay or Etsy and your own store, covering costs, control, customer data and risk.
Commission is only the start. We break down referral, fulfilment, storage, advertising, payment, returns and currency costs, with an illustrative margin example.
From card authorisation to payout: acquirers, PSPs, split payments, SCA, chargebacks, payout holds, reserves and currency conversion, explained for sellers.