How EU platform rules affect online sellers: DSA, DMA, P2B, GPSR and the Omnibus Directive
An analysis of how the DSA, DMA, P2B Regulation, GPSR and Omnibus Directive shape what marketplace sellers must provide, display and expect from platforms.
The 14-day withdrawal right, refund deadlines, return costs, the EU online withdrawal function, legal guarantees and cross-border rules for online sellers.
Returns are where consumer law meets an online shop’s margins most directly. The rules on withdrawal, refunds and faulty goods are largely harmonised across the EU, broadly mirrored in the UK, and were tightened in June 2026 with a new requirement for an online withdrawal function. This guide sets out what applies as of November 2026, including what changes when you sell across borders.
Online sellers often blur two separate consumer rights. The right of withdrawal lets a consumer cancel a distance contract within a fixed period for any reason or none. The legal guarantee (sometimes called statutory warranty) gives remedies when goods are faulty or not as described, for a much longer period. A returns policy that says “returns accepted within 14 days” addresses only the first; it does not limit the second. Neither right can be removed by contract terms.
The Consumer Rights Directive 2011/83/EU gives consumers 14 days to withdraw from a distance or off-premises contract (Article 9). For goods, the period runs from the day the consumer, or a third party they nominate other than the carrier, takes physical possession. For multiple items delivered separately under one order, it runs from receipt of the last item. For services, it runs from conclusion of the contract.
If the trader fails to give the required information about the right of withdrawal, the period is extended by up to 12 months (Article 10). This is one of the costliest mistakes in practice: a shop with a missing or wrong withdrawal notice can face returns long after the sale.
Article 16 lists contracts where there is no withdrawal right, including:
The exceptions are interpreted narrowly. A T-shirt chosen in a standard size and colour is not “personalised”; one printed with the customer’s name is.
Under Article 13, the trader must reimburse all payments received, including the cost of standard delivery, without undue delay and no later than 14 days after being informed of the decision to withdraw. If the consumer chose a more expensive delivery method than the cheapest standard option, the extra cost need not be refunded. Reimbursement must use the same means of payment the consumer used, unless the consumer expressly agrees otherwise and incurs no fees. Store credit cannot be imposed.
For goods, the trader may withhold reimbursement until it has received the goods back or the consumer has supplied evidence of having sent them, whichever is earlier, unless the trader offered to collect them.
Under Article 14, the consumer must send the goods back within 14 days of withdrawing and bears the direct cost of return, unless the trader agreed to bear it or failed to tell the consumer that they would have to pay. The consumer is liable only for any diminished value resulting from handling beyond what is necessary to establish the nature, characteristics and functioning of the goods, the kind of inspection a customer could do in a shop.
Illustrative example: a customer orders a €120 jacket with €5 standard delivery, tries it on and withdraws on day 10. The trader refunds €125 within 14 days of the notice, or as soon as the parcel or proof of posting arrives if that is earlier. If the jacket comes back with tags removed and a stain, the trader may deduct an amount reflecting the reduced value, but not refuse the refund outright.
Traders must provide the model withdrawal form in Annex I(B) of the Directive as part of their pre-contractual information. Consumers may use it or any other unequivocal statement, such as an email. Traders may also offer an online form, but must then acknowledge receipt on a durable medium without delay.
Directive (EU) 2023/2673, adopted mainly to update rules on financial services sold at a distance, inserted a new Article 11a into the Consumer Rights Directive that applies to all distance contracts concluded through an online interface where a withdrawal right exists. Member states had to transpose it by 19 December 2025 and apply it from 19 June 2026. Germany, for example, implemented it in a new § 356a of the Civil Code, effective on that date. Transposition has not been equally prompt everywhere, so check the national law in each country you sell to.
Article 11a requires:
A withdrawal is in time if the statement is submitted before the period expires. Pre-contractual information must now mention the existence and placement of the function.
In our assessment, the practical difficulty is availability “throughout the withdrawal period” for guest checkouts. A function only inside a customer account does not help a consumer who ordered without one. Many shops are solving this with a public page where the consumer enters an order number and email address. Do not add friction such as mandatory reason fields or login walls; the Directive’s aim is that withdrawing online should be as easy as buying.
The Sale of Goods Directive (EU) 2019/771, applicable to contracts concluded since 1 January 2022, makes the seller liable for any lack of conformity that becomes apparent within at least two years of delivery; some member states set longer periods. Any defect that appears within one year of delivery is presumed to have existed at delivery unless the seller proves otherwise, and member states may extend that presumption to two years.
The consumer first chooses between repair and replacement, unless the chosen remedy is impossible or disproportionate. Either must be free of charge, within a reasonable time and without significant inconvenience. If that fails, or the seller refuses, the consumer can claim a proportionate price reduction or terminate the contract, though not for a minor lack of conformity. A seller cannot redirect consumers to the manufacturer instead of meeting these obligations, although a manufacturer’s commercial guarantee can be offered in addition.
Under Article 6 of the Rome I Regulation, a consumer contract is governed by the law of the consumer’s habitual residence if the trader pursues commercial activities in that country or directs activities to it. The parties may choose another law, but the choice cannot deprive the consumer of the protection of mandatory rules in their home country. A German shop that targets French customers and specifies German law in its terms will still have to honour any stronger French consumer protections.
Under Articles 17 and 18 of the Brussels I bis Regulation, the same “directing activities” test decides jurisdiction. A consumer may sue in their own country’s courts, and the trader can sue the consumer only there. In Pammer and Hotel Alpenhof (C-585/08 and C-144/09), the Court of Justice held that a website merely being accessible is not enough; indications include international dialling codes, use of another country’s language or currency, country-specific domains, and references to customers from other member states.
The Geo-blocking Regulation (EU) 2018/302, applicable since 3 December 2018, prevents traders from blocking or automatically redirecting customers based on nationality or location without consent, and from applying different general conditions of access in specified situations, such as when a customer from another member state wants goods delivered to an address where the trader offers delivery or collected at an agreed location. It also bars discrimination between payment means the trader accepts based on where the card or account was issued. It does not oblige you to deliver everywhere. Article 1(6) confirms that complying with it does not by itself mean you are directing activities to a country for Rome I and Brussels I bis purposes. The Commission is evaluating the Regulation; at the time of writing no amendment has been proposed.
Great Britain is outside these EU instruments, but its rules are similar. The Consumer Contracts Regulations 2013 give a 14-day cancellation period for distance contracts, extended by up to 12 months where cancellation information is not given; require refunds within 14 days, with the same option to wait for the goods or proof of return; and provide a model cancellation form in Schedule 3. There is no UK equivalent of the EU withdrawal function. Faulty goods are covered by the Consumer Rights Act 2015, which provides a 30-day short-term right to reject, then repair or replacement, and then a price reduction or final right to reject. Faults appearing within six months are presumed to have existed at delivery.
The UK’s separate regime for subscription contracts under the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 had not commenced at the time of writing and is expected in 2027. A UK shop selling to EU consumers must apply EU rules, including the withdrawal function, to those sales if it directs its activities to the EU.
Clear, generous-but-lawful return terms are also a commercial asset; our guide to building customer trust as a small online retailer looks at that side. Sellers on marketplaces should check how the platform’s own returns process maps onto these duties, as discussed in our analysis of EU platform rules for online sellers and our comparison of marketplace selling and running your own store. Refunds also interact with chargebacks, covered in how marketplace payments work.
This article is general information, not legal advice; for decisions about your business, consult a qualified adviser.
An analysis of how the DSA, DMA, P2B Regulation, GPSR and Omnibus Directive shape what marketplace sellers must provide, display and expect from platforms.
How ePrivacy, the GDPR, Planet49, EDPB and CNIL guidance and the UK's 2026 PECR changes apply to cookie banners, analytics and Google Consent Mode.
Early studies found falls in recorded EU web traffic and revenue after the GDPR. We revisit what they measured, what they could not, and the lessons for analytics today.