Digital Regulation & Privacy Retrospective

Google v CNIL and the territorial limits of the right to be forgotten

In September 2019 the EU Court of Justice ruled that de-referencing need not be global. What it decided, what followed, and why it matters for online reputation.

Key points

  • In Case C-507/17 (24 September 2019) the Court held that EU law does not currently require de-referencing on every version of a search engine, but does require it on the versions for all member states.
  • Search engines must also take measures that effectively prevent, or at least seriously discourage, EU users from reaching de-referenced links through non-EU versions.
  • The Court left national authorities free to order worldwide de-referencing after balancing privacy against freedom of information under national standards.
  • The same day, GC and Others (C-136/17) applied the GDPR's special-category rules to search engines and set factors for old criminal-proceedings reports.
  • In C-460/20 (December 2022) the Court added that manifestly inaccurate information must be de-referenced when the requester provides sufficient evidence, without needing a court ruling.
  • The right protects individuals, not companies, so businesses cannot use it to remove criticism of the firm itself.

On 24 September 2019 the Court of Justice of the European Union answered a question that had been building since 2014: when a search engine agrees to remove a result under the “right to be forgotten”, does it have to do so everywhere in the world? The answer was no, with significant qualifications. Delivered alongside a second judgment on sensitive data, the ruling still frames how de-referencing works for individuals and, indirectly, for the businesses they run.

Background: from Google Spain to the GDPR

The starting point is Google Spain (C-131/12), decided by the Court on 13 May 2014. It held that a search engine operator processes personal data when it indexes and displays web pages, and that a person can ask for links to be removed from results for searches on their name, even where the underlying page stays online and was lawfully published. Search engines then built request processes, initially applying removals to their European domains.

The GDPR, applicable from 25 May 2018, codified a “right to erasure” in Article 17, together with exceptions. The most important for search is Article 17(3)(a): erasure does not apply where processing is necessary for exercising the right of freedom of expression and information. That balancing test sits at the centre of every de-referencing request.

Google v CNIL: the territorial question

France’s data protection authority, the CNIL, took the view that a removal must apply on every version of the search engine, not only on European domains. After a formal notice on 21 May 2015, it fined Google €100,000 on 10 March 2016 for refusing to apply de-referencing across all domain extensions. Google challenged the fine before the Conseil d’État, which referred questions to Luxembourg.

In Case C-507/17 the Court accepted that a worldwide removal would fully achieve the objective of protecting the person concerned, given that information accessed from outside the EU can have immediate effects inside it. But it noted that many non-EU countries do not recognise a right to de-referencing, or take a different approach, and that the balance between privacy and freedom of information varies around the world. Nothing in the EU legislation showed that the legislature had struck that balance for removals outside the EU.

Its conclusions were threefold:

  1. No global obligation. Under EU law as it then stood, a search engine operator granting a request is not required to de-reference on all versions of its search engine.
  2. An EU-wide obligation, with teeth. It must de-reference on the versions corresponding to all member states, and where necessary take measures that effectively prevent or at least seriously discourage a user searching from a member state from reaching the links through a non-EU version. Geo-blocking was the obvious example; the Court left it to the national court to assess whether Google’s measures were enough.
  3. No prohibition either. EU law does not forbid worldwide de-referencing. National authorities may, after weighing privacy against freedom of information under national standards of fundamental-rights protection, order it in a particular case.

The French follow-up came on 27 March 2020, when the Conseil d’État annulled the CNIL’s €100,000 sanction. It held that the CNIL had erred in law by demanding worldwide removal without the balancing exercise the Court of Justice described.

GC and Others: sensitive data and old news

The same day, in GC and Others (C-136/17), the Court dealt with four people whose requests the CNIL had declined to pursue. The links concerned a satirical photomontage of a politician, a reference to one person’s past role at the Church of Scientology, a judicial investigation of a politician and a conviction for sexual offences.

The Court held that the prohibitions on processing special categories of data (such as political opinions, religious beliefs and sex life) and the restrictions on criminal-offence data apply to search engines too. Because a search engine is responsible for the referencing of a page rather than its content, those rules bite through the request process: once a request is made, the operator must check whether keeping a link to sensitive data is strictly necessary to protect the freedom of information of users who might want it.

For reports of criminal proceedings that no longer reflect the current position, the Court listed factors to weigh, including the seriousness of the offence, the progress and outcome of the case, the time elapsed, the person’s role in public life and the public’s interest at the time of the request. Even where a link stays, the operator must arrange results so that the overall picture reflects the current legal position, with up-to-date information appearing first.

What happened next

The European Data Protection Board adopted the final version of its Guidelines 5/2019 on search-engine de-referencing on 7 July 2020, setting out the grounds for requests and how the Article 17(3) exceptions apply.

On 8 December 2022 the Court decided Case C-460/20, a reference from Germany’s Federal Court of Justice. Two managers of a group of investment companies wanted Google to de-reference critical articles they said were inaccurate, and to remove thumbnail photos of them from image results. The Court held that freedom of information cannot be relied on where a part of the information that is not of minor importance is inaccurate. The requester must show manifest inaccuracy, but only with evidence they can reasonably be expected to find; they need not first obtain a court ruling against the publisher. Where they do, the search engine must act. Where inaccuracy is not obvious, the operator need not remove the link, but must warn users of any pending administrative or court proceedings it knows about. Thumbnails shown out of context call for their own, separate balancing exercise.

Where things stand (as of November 2026)

The structure set in 2019 still holds. A successful request leads to removal across EU versions of a search engine, supported by geo-based measures, while national authorities retain the option of seeking wider removal after a case-specific balancing. Requests are assessed under Article 17 GDPR, with the factors from GC and Others and the evidential approach in C-460/20. We are not aware of any later Court of Justice ruling that has changed the territorial position.

What it means for businesses

The right belongs to people, not companies

The GDPR protects natural persons; recital 14 confirms it does not cover data about legal persons such as a company’s name and contact details. A company cannot use Article 17 to remove an unflattering news story or review about the firm itself. In a related context, the Court held in Manni (C-398/15) on 9 March 2017 that individuals named in company registers have no general right to erasure after a set period; any restriction of access is for member states to decide, case by case.

But founders, directors and sole traders are people

Results about a named individual are a different matter. A sole trader, a director whose name appears in old coverage, or a founder linked to a long-closed insolvency may have grounds to request de-referencing. The weight given to their role in public life matters: an active, prominent business figure will find the balance tilts towards public access more often than a former employee.

Practical steps

  • Use the search engine’s own request form, and explain why each link is inaccurate, outdated or disproportionate, with supporting evidence.
  • Expect removal to apply to EU searches, not everywhere.
  • For content that is unlawful rather than merely unwelcome, consider the host’s reporting tools and other legal routes; our analysis of EU digital-platform rules for online sellers explains the Digital Services Act’s notice-and-action system.
  • Remember the other side: if your business publishes information about identifiable people, such as staff profiles or case studies, you are a controller with your own erasure obligations. Our guide to GDPR obligations for online businesses covers handling those requests, and building customer trust discusses responding constructively to criticism.

Bottom line

Google v CNIL drew a line at the EU’s edge without sealing it: removal across the Union is the rule, worldwide removal remains possible but exceptional. For businesses, the more practical lesson is about who holds the right. Individuals can ask for old or inaccurate results to be removed; companies need other tools.

This article is general information about past and current law, not legal advice.

Sources and further reading

  1. Judgment of 24 September 2019, Google LLC v CNIL, Case C-507/17 — EUR-Lex
  2. Press release No 112/19: judgment in Case C-507/17 Google v CNIL — Court of Justice of the European Union
  3. Press release No 113/19: judgment in Case C-136/17 GC and Others v CNIL — Court of Justice of the European Union
  4. Judgment of 13 May 2014, Google Spain and Google, Case C-131/12 — EUR-Lex
  5. Press release No 197/22: judgment in Case C-460/20 Google (de-referencing of allegedly inaccurate content) — Court of Justice of the European Union
  6. Conseil d'État, decision No 399922 of 27 March 2020 (French) — Conseil d'État
  7. Guidelines 5/2019 on the criteria of the right to be forgotten in the search engines cases under the GDPR — European Data Protection Board
  8. Regulation (EU) 2016/679 (General Data Protection Regulation) — EUR-Lex