Digital Regulation & Privacy Retrospective

Germany's 2019 GDPR fines: Delivery Hero, Deutsche Wohnen, 1&1 and what followed

How Berlin's €195,407 Delivery Hero fine opened a run of German GDPR enforcement in late 2019, and what the court cases that followed mean for online firms.

Key points

  • Berlin's data protection authority announced fines totalling €195,407 against Delivery Hero Germany GmbH on 19 September 2019, mostly for failures to honour access, erasure and objection rights.
  • Within three months German authorities adopted a turnover-based fining model and announced fines of about €14.5 million against Deutsche Wohnen and €9.55 million against 1&1 Telecom.
  • Courts later cut both large fines to €900,000: the Bonn Regional Court for 1&1 in November 2020, and the Berlin Regional Court I for Deutsche Wohnen in June 2026 (not yet final at that point).
  • The Court of Justice ruled on 5 December 2023 that a company can be fined without identifying a responsible manager, but only for an intentional or negligent infringement.
  • The practical lesson is unchanged: online businesses need working processes for access requests, marketing objections and deletion, not just a privacy policy.

In September 2019 Berlin’s data protection authority announced that it had fined the German arm of a food-delivery group for ignoring its customers’ basic GDPR rights. The sum, €195,407, was modest, but the case opened three months in which German regulators set out how they intended to fine companies and imposed their first multi-million-euro penalties. Seven years on, most of those cases have been through the courts, and the results are instructive.

The Delivery Hero fine

On 19 September 2019 the Berlin Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information announced that in August 2019 the authority had imposed fines totalling €195,407, including fees, on Delivery Hero Germany GmbH. The decision was already final. It was widely reported at the time as the largest fine a German authority had imposed in the GDPR era, although part of it was assessed under the pre-GDPR law because some of the conduct predated 25 May 2018; the authority issued two separate decisions for that reason.

The authority’s findings were unglamorous, which is what makes them useful. According to the press release:

  • in ten cases the company had not deleted the accounts of former customers who had been inactive on the platform for years, in one case since 2008;
  • eight former customers complained about unwanted marketing emails, and one complainant who had expressly objected to the use of their data for advertising received 15 further marketing emails;
  • in five further cases the company did not answer requests for access to personal data, or did so only after the authority intervened.

The company attributed some failings to technical errors or staff oversights. The authority’s view was that the number of repeated breaches pointed to fundamental, structural organisational problems, and that adequate measures had not been taken over a long period despite repeated warnings. The Berlin authority stressed that any business processing personal data must be technically and organisationally able to fulfil data subject requests without delay.

There was a corporate twist. On 1 April 2019 the Delivery Hero brands Lieferheld, Pizza.de and foodora had been acquired by Takeaway.com. All the breaches predated the takeover; the new owner accepted the fines and did not appeal.

The rest of 2019: a fining model and two large penalties

A common German approach to fines

On 14 October 2019 the conference of German federal and state data protection authorities (DSK) adopted a concept for setting fines against companies. It worked in five steps: place the company in a size class by its previous year’s worldwide turnover; take the average turnover of that subgroup; divide by 360 to produce a daily “economic base value”; multiply by a factor reflecting the severity of the infringement; then adjust for circumstances relating to the offender. The concept said it was not binding on courts or in cross-border cases, and that it would lapse once the European Data Protection Board adopted final guidelines on fine calculation.

Deutsche Wohnen: a “data graveyard”

On 30 October 2019 the Berlin authority issued a fine of about €14.5 million against the property company Deutsche Wohnen SE, announced on 5 November. Inspections in June 2017 and March 2019 had found tenants’ data stored in an archive system with no means of deleting information that was no longer needed, including payslips, bank statements and tax, social security and health insurance details. The authority found breaches of Article 25(1) (data protection by design) and Article 5 of the GDPR for May 2018 to March 2019. Based on 2018 turnover of more than €1 billion, it put the statutory ceiling at about €28 million and chose a fine in the middle of the range. It also imposed separate fines of €6,000 to €17,000 in 15 individual cases.

1&1 Telecom: who is on the phone?

On 9 December 2019 the Federal Commissioner (BfDI) announced a fine of €9,550,000 against 1&1 Telecom GmbH. Callers to its customer hotline had been able to obtain extensive personal information about a customer simply by giving the customer’s name and date of birth. The BfDI treated this as a breach of the security obligation in Article 32 GDPR, noting that the whole customer base was exposed, and said the fine sat in the lower part of the available range because the company had cooperated.

What the courts did next

Case Original fine Later outcome
Delivery Hero Germany €195,407 (August 2019) Accepted; final
1&1 Telecom €9.55 million (December 2019) Reduced to €900,000 by Bonn Regional Court, 11 November 2020
Deutsche Wohnen about €14.5 million (October 2019) Reduced to €900,000 by Berlin Regional Court I, 9 June 2026; not final at that date

In 1&1’s case the Bonn Regional Court confirmed on 11 November 2020 that the company had breached its Article 32 duties but set the fine at €900,000. The judgment criticised a calculation anchored mainly on turnover, as in the DSK concept, saying such a method fails for minor breaches by high-turnover companies and serious breaches by low-turnover ones; the case-specific criteria in Article 83(2) GDPR must take priority.

Deutsche Wohnen took a longer road. On 18 February 2021 the Berlin Regional Court discontinued the proceedings, holding that a company could be fined only if a specific act by a manager or legal representative was established. The prosecution appealed, and in December 2021 the Berlin Court of Appeal (Kammergericht) referred questions to the Court of Justice of the EU. On 5 December 2023 the Court ruled in Case C-807/21 that a fine on a legal person cannot be made conditional on first attributing the infringement to an identified natural person, but that a fine requires the infringement to have been committed intentionally or negligently. It added that where the company belongs to a group, the maximum fine is based on the turnover of the whole undertaking.

The case returned to the Berlin courts. On 9 June 2026 the Berlin Regional Court I found that Deutsche Wohnen had intentionally breached the data minimisation and storage limitation principles between 25 May 2018 and 5 March 2019, and fined it €900,000. The court took into account the company’s use of external auditors and consultants, the early phase of the GDPR, and the difficulties the authority itself had faced in adapting to the new law. The court’s press release stated that the judgment was not yet final and could be challenged on points of law.

Meanwhile the DSK concept lapsed by its own terms: the European Data Protection Board adopted the final version of its Guidelines 04/2022 on calculating fines on 24 May 2023.

Where things stand (as of November 2026)

Three points are settled. German authorities can fine companies directly, without naming a responsible manager, but must show intent or negligence. Fine calculation is now governed by EDPB methodology rather than a purely national formula, with turnover a factor rather than the starting point. And German courts have been willing to reduce large fines substantially when they consider the amount disproportionate to the circumstances or the method too mechanical. We have not seen a published decision on any further appeal in the Deutsche Wohnen case at the time of writing; readers relying on it should check its current status.

Our assessment: what online businesses should take from it

The headline numbers attracted attention in 2019, but the Delivery Hero case is the more relevant precedent for most online shops, because its failures are the ones a growing business is most likely to repeat.

  1. Treat data subject requests as a process, not an inbox. The GDPR normally requires a response within one month. Log each request, assign an owner and keep evidence of the reply.
  2. Make marketing objections stick. An objection to direct marketing under Article 21 is absolute. It must reach every system that sends email, including legacy tools and agencies, and suppression lists should survive data migrations.
  3. Set and enforce retention periods. Dormant customer accounts are a liability, as both Delivery Hero and Deutsche Wohnen showed. Decide how long inactive accounts are kept, then automate deletion or anonymisation.
  4. Verify identity before disclosing data. The 1&1 case is a reminder that a hotline or chat agent revealing details on the strength of a name and birth date is a security failure, not good service.
  5. Document your reasoning. After C-807/21, fines turn on whether a company acted intentionally or negligently. Records showing that risks were considered and addressed are part of the defence.

Our guide to GDPR obligations for online businesses covers response deadlines and retention in more detail, and protecting ecommerce customer accounts and data security basics for online retailers address the authentication and storage lessons from 1&1 and Deutsche Wohnen.

Bottom line

Germany’s 2019 cases began as a test of whether regulators would enforce the GDPR’s individual rights and ended as a long argument about how fines should be calculated and who can be held responsible. The arithmetic has changed; the underlying expectation, that a business can actually honour the rights it promises, has not.

This article is general information about past and current law, not legal advice.

Sources and further reading

  1. Press release of 19 September 2019: fines against Delivery Hero Germany GmbH and N26 (German) — Berliner Beauftragte für Datenschutz und Informationsfreiheit
  2. Press release of 5 November 2019: fine against a real estate company (German) — Berliner Beauftragte für Datenschutz und Informationsfreiheit
  3. Concept of the German supervisory authorities for setting fines in proceedings against companies, 14 October 2019 (German) — Datenschutzkonferenz (DSK)
  4. Press release 30/2019: BfDI imposes fines on telecommunications service providers (German) — Bundesbeauftragter für den Datenschutz und die Informationsfreiheit (BfDI)
  5. Landgericht Bonn, judgment of 11 November 2020, 29 OWi 1/20 (German) — Justiz NRW (NRWE)
  6. Press release No 184/23: judgments in Cases C-683/21 and C-807/21 Deutsche Wohnen — Court of Justice of the European Union
  7. Press release 24/2026: Landgericht Berlin I imposes fine on Deutsche Wohnen for GDPR infringements (German) — Berlin courts (Berlin.de)
  8. Guidelines 04/2022 on the calculation of administrative fines under the GDPR — European Data Protection Board