Local commerce and the growth of secondhand marketplaces

Classifieds versus managed resale, how secondhand platforms make money, safety for in-person exchanges, and what DAC7 and trader status mean for sellers.

Key points

  • Secondhand platforms split into classifieds, which connect people, and managed marketplaces, which also handle payment, shipping and disputes.
  • Many resale platforms now charge buyers rather than private sellers, through a buyer protection fee added at checkout.
  • Under DAC7, platforms report sellers to tax authorities unless they sold fewer than 30 goods for no more than €2,000 in a year; a June 2026 proposal would change this to a single €3,000 threshold.
  • Being reported is not the same as owing tax, but frequent profit-seeking sales can make a private seller a trader in law.
  • In-person exchanges are safest in busy public places, with payment completed before items change hands and never via links sent by the other party.

Selling a used sofa to a neighbour and shipping a vintage jacket to a buyer three countries away are now both routine online transactions, but they run on very different platform models with different risks. Secondhand commerce has moved from the margins of ecommerce towards its centre, and regulators — particularly tax authorities — have followed it. This analysis looks at how local and resale marketplaces work, how they make money, and what has changed for the people who sell on them.

Two models: classifieds and managed marketplaces

Secondhand platforms broadly fall into two families, with many hybrids in between.

Classifieds — the model behind Craigslist, much of Facebook Marketplace and the traditional core of Leboncoin — connect a buyer and seller and then step back. The parties agree terms by message, usually meet in person, and settle payment between themselves. The platform’s role is discovery and messaging; it typically does not hold money or arbitrate disputes.

Managed marketplaces — Vinted and eBay are the best-known examples in Europe — sit inside the transaction. The buyer pays through the platform, the item is usually shipped, often with a label or delivery option the platform provides, and the money is released to the seller only after delivery or a short inspection window. When something goes wrong, the platform decides.

Classifieds Managed marketplace
Typical exchange Local pickup, cash or bank transfer Shipped, paid at checkout
Platform holds payment Usually no Yes
Dispute handling Mostly left to the parties Platform decides, within published rules
Main revenue Advertising, paid listing options, category fees Buyer or seller fees, shipping, promoted listings
Best suited to Bulky, low-value or local items Small, shippable items; clothing, media, collectables
Main risk Fraud and personal safety in the exchange Disputes over condition; account suspensions

The boundary is blurring. Classifieds operators have added integrated payment and delivery options in some markets, and managed platforms have added local pickup. In our view, the direction of travel is towards more platform involvement in the transaction, because that is where both the safety benefits and the revenue lie.

Why secondhand has grown

The drivers are a mix of economics, habit and policy, and we describe them qualitatively because reliable, comparable cross-country data on the size of consumer-to-consumer resale is scarce.

Cost pressure. Periods of high inflation make buying used more attractive and give households a reason to turn unused possessions into cash.

Lower friction. Smartphone listing — photograph, describe, price, done — and prepaid shipping labels have made selling a single item worth the effort in a way that classified newspaper adverts never were. Integrated payment removed the awkwardness of negotiating with strangers about how to pay.

Changing norms. Buying secondhand clothing, electronics and furniture carries far less stigma than it once did, particularly among younger shoppers, and resale value has become part of how some people think about buying new.

Policy direction. The European Commission’s circular economy agenda — the 2020 Circular Economy Action Plan, and a Circular Economy Act that the Commission says is due for adoption in 2026 — aims to keep products and materials in use for longer. At the time of writing we could not confirm that the Act has been formally proposed, so its implications for resale remain to be seen. Policy does not create demand by itself, but it shapes product design, repair and waste rules in ways that favour reuse.

How the platforms make money

Secondhand platforms face a structural problem: private sellers are price-sensitive, the items are often low-value, and a heavy commission can make a sale not worth the effort. Platforms have responded with several revenue models, often in combination.

Buyer-paid protection fees. A growing number of managed marketplaces charge private sellers nothing to list or sell, and instead add a fee for the buyer at checkout that funds payment holding, refunds and support. Vinted’s help centre describes its fee — recently renamed from “Buyer Protection fee” to Vinted fee — as a mandatory charge combining a percentage of the price with a fixed amount. eBay UK applies a Buyer Protection fee, paid by the buyer, on purchases from UK private sellers, while purchases from business sellers include protection at no extra cost to the buyer. Exact rates vary and change; check the platform’s own fee page rather than relying on figures quoted elsewhere.

Seller commissions and listing fees. Business sellers, and private sellers on some platforms, pay a percentage of the sale price, sometimes with a per-order charge and listing fees above a free allowance.

Promoted listings and “bumps”. Paying to push a listing up the results is a large and growing revenue line. It is also where sellers should be most disciplined: on a low-value item, a promotion fee can absorb most of the margin.

Subscriptions and pro tools. Professional resellers may pay for shop features, bulk listing tools or analytics.

Shipping and payments. Integrated shipping and payment services can generate margin in their own right.

For buyers, the shift to buyer-paid fees means the listed price is not the price paid. For sellers, it means that fee-free selling still has costs: time, packaging, and the risk of returns or disputes being decided against them. We look at protection mechanisms more broadly in what makes a trustworthy online marketplace.

Safety in local exchanges

Most of the risk in classifieds sits in two moments: payment and the physical meeting. Fraud patterns are well documented — fake payment confirmation emails, requests to move the conversation to another app, “courier” links that harvest card details, and overpayment scams. Our guide to common online marketplace scams covers them in detail.

For in-person exchanges, a few rules cover most situations:

  • Meet in a busy, well-lit public place during the day, ideally one with CCTV, and tell someone where you are going. For large items that must be collected from a home, have another person present.
  • Inspect the item before paying, and test electronics where possible.
  • Complete payment before the item changes hands, using a method you control. Never click a payment link sent by the other party, and check incoming payments in your own banking or payment app rather than trusting a screenshot or email.
  • Be wary of pressure, last-minute changes of plan and requests to pay a deposit for an item you have not seen.
  • Where the platform offers integrated payment with buyer protection, use it; once you pay off-platform, platform protection generally no longer applies.

The tax question: DAC7 and platform reporting

Since 1 January 2023, the EU’s DAC7 directive has required digital platforms to collect information about sellers and report it to tax authorities each year, with reports due by 31 January for the previous calendar year. Platforms must collect, for individual sellers, their name, primary address, tax identification number (or place of birth if they have none), VAT number where available and date of birth. If a seller does not provide the information after two reminders, and no sooner than 60 days after the first request, the platform must close the account and prevent re-registration, or withhold payments until the information is provided.

Sellers of goods are excluded from reporting if, in a calendar year, they made fewer than 30 sales and received no more than €2,000. Both conditions must be met: someone who sells 40 items for €600 is reportable under the current rules. The UK operates equivalent rules; HMRC’s guidance gives the same threshold of fewer than 30 sales and less than €2,000 (about £1,700).

That combination has caught a large number of casual sellers. On 24 June 2026 the Commission proposed a recast of the administrative cooperation directive that would raise the reporting threshold for online sales of goods. The Commission’s supporting documents describe removing the 30-sale criterion and setting a single €3,000 threshold, and the Commission says the change would remove reporting obligations from over 10 million sellers, particularly private sellers of secondhand goods. As of November 2026 this is a proposal: tax directives require unanimous agreement in the Council, and the current thresholds continue to apply until any change is adopted and implemented.

Two points are widely misunderstood. First, DAC7 creates no new tax; it gives tax authorities information. HMRC states that people selling personal items from their home are unlikely to pay tax, whereas buying or making goods to sell for profit is likely to be trading. Rules differ between countries, so sellers should check with their national tax authority. Second, being below the reporting threshold does not make income tax-free if it is taxable under national law.

Private seller or trader?

The other legal line that matters is between consumers and traders. Since the Omnibus Directive took effect, EU marketplaces must tell buyers whether a seller is a trader, based on the seller’s own declaration, and that EU consumer protection rules — such as the 14-day right of withdrawal — do not apply to purchases from private individuals.

Self-declaration is not the end of the matter. In Kamenova (C-105/17), the Court of Justice held that a person selling multiple items online is not automatically a trader; it requires a case-by-case assessment of factors such as whether the sales are organised, profit-motivated and frequent, whether the seller has more information or technical knowledge than the buyer, and whether they are registered for VAT. Illustrative example: someone clearing out their wardrobe twice a year is very likely a consumer; someone buying job lots of branded trainers each week to resell at a margin is very likely a trader, whatever box they tick. Traders take on obligations — withdrawal rights, legal guarantees, trader identification — that our guide to returns, refunds and cross-border selling explains, and platforms may ask them for business verification, covered in our guide to marketplace seller onboarding and verification.

Our assessment

In our view, secondhand commerce is maturing in the way most marketplace categories eventually do: platforms take on more of the transaction, charge for the safety they provide, and attract regulation designed for professional sellers. The buyer-fee model has made casual selling easier, but it shifts costs to buyers in a way that is not always obvious from the listed price.

DAC7 was designed with the gig economy and professional sellers in mind, and the Commission’s own proposal to raise the threshold implicitly acknowledges that the current design catches too many people clearing out their homes. Until that changes, private sellers should expect to provide tax details to the platforms they use, and should not read a reporting notice as a tax bill. The more significant line for anyone selling regularly is the trader test, which turns on behaviour rather than on any number.

Bottom line

Choose classifieds for bulky or local items and be strict about payment and meeting safety; choose managed platforms for shippable items and stay inside their payment flow. If you sell regularly, keep simple records of what you bought, what you sold and for how much — they will answer both the tax question and the trader question if either is ever asked.

This article is general information as of November 2026, not legal or tax advice.

Sources and further reading

  1. Council Directive (EU) 2021/514 (DAC7) amending Directive 2011/16/EU on administrative cooperation in the field of taxation — EUR-Lex
  2. European Commission proposes landmark tax simplification package to streamline compliance and boost competitiveness — European Commission, Taxation and Customs Union
  3. Selling goods or services on a digital platform — HM Revenue & Customs (GOV.UK)
  4. Directive (EU) 2019/2161 – Omnibus Directive — EUR-Lex
  5. Judgment of the Court of Justice in Case C-105/17, Kamenova — EUR-Lex
  6. Circular economy — European Commission, Directorate-General for Environment
  7. Buyer Protection fee — eBay UK Help
  8. Vinted fee (formerly Buyer Protection fee) — Vinted Help Centre